A Class Divided Reaction Essay Samples

Teaching about prejudice and racism calls for more than just direct instruction and lecture. Using inductive teaching strategies is crucial to grabbing students’ attention. Some of the most memorable lessons that I have taught incorporated some authentic role-playing on my part.

The best example of authentic role-playing by a teachers is featured in the PBS Frontline film, “A Class Divided.” Jane Elliott divided her class into two groups: those with brown eyes and those with blue eyes. She introduced her simulation as a way of teaching about discrimination in the wake of Martin Luther King Jr’s death. She purposefully treated blue eyed students better than the brown eyed students and gave one group more rights than the other.

The students were given a concrete experience of racism that they would never forget. This group of all white students were now able to put themselves in the shoes of people who suffer from discrimination and racism, even if it was only for a short time.

I tried this with my students in conjunction with showing the PBS film. For the first fifteen minutes of class, they were separated into brown eyed students and blue eyed students. Surprisingly, a group of high school juniors actually believed that I held blue eyed people in higher esteem, even though I had been their teacher for months.

It all made sense when watching the movie. They could put themselves in the shoes of the students (and more importantly those who suffered and continue to suffer the effects of racism in our world). It was one of the lessons that the kids were talking about in the halls. One girl came into the class later that day for a different session and said, “I heard we have a great class planned today. What are we doing?” She had blue eyes, so I praised her for asking such an astute question.

Try this or another inductive teaching simulation. Instead of leading with the facts in an organized, structured way (deductive teaching), lead with a story, an experience, an authentic role-play, or a simulation (inductive teaching). Use this concrete experience throughout the unit as a teaching tool.

Showing the PBS Frontline Movie: A Class Divided

This movie is available for free at PBS Frontline (you need an Internet connection). When I first showed it, I used the copy that we had in the school library, but I’m not able to find a good location to purchase the DVD online.

Disclaimer: Make sure you provide a disclaimer to the video. Because of the time period in with it was shot, there is some language that is offensive to us today.

A Class Divided Video Discussion Questions

  1. What was it like to be a blue eyed student?
  2. How do you think you would react in their situation?
  3. Who suffers discrimination in our country today? How is their experience similar to this film?
  4. What caused the kids to be so mean to one another? What would you say is the cause of racism?
  5. How did things change once the kids roles were switched?

(I just found a great follow-up activity. Send your students to the PBS website (Join the Discussion) and have them enter their reactions to viewing the movie online. Have the click “share your thoughts” and enter in their responses.)

Filed Under: Social Justice, Teaching StrategiesTagged With: prejudice, racism, video

Chase MillerSociologyA Class Divided ReactionThe movie we watched in class really surprised me. I have learned about discrimination and racism before, but I do not believe a video has had that same affect on me. It amazes me that both the children and the workers had the same exactly reaction during her experiment/lesson. Both groups of people truly believed in their superiority solely because of eye color.  First, the children seemed to believe everything their teacher told them. In the video, she said that she started this experiment right after Dr. Martin Luther King's deathso it was obviously during the height of the civil rights movement. The children, before the experiment, had already had certain biases against people in place, which caught me off guard. For example, they already believed that people who had red, brown, or yellow skin were beneath them because they had white skin. I can see this today even in children my age, and younger. Many people truly believe that people with white skin are superior to those without, which truly makes me sad. I go to LSA and many of my classmates are white, but I do not believe there is much discrimination within my school towards the few black students we do have. All throughout elementary school to now one of my closest friends was a mixed boy. I cannot understand why people associate 

0 thoughts on “A Class Divided Reaction Essay Samples

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *