Aims McGuinness.Path of Empire: Panama and the California Gold Rush. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2008. 264 S. $35.00 (cloth), ISBN 978-0-8014-4521-7.
Reviewed by Torsten Loschke
Published on H-Soz-u-Kult (November, 2008)
A. McGuinness: Path of Empire
The last years witnessed efforts to establish a transnational perspective on the history of the United States, arguing that American history can only be understood and explained by regarding the country’s transnational and global entanglements. See for example: Tyrell, Ian, Transnational Nation. United States history in global perspective since 1789, Basingstoke 2007; Bender, Thomas, A Nation among Nations. America’s Place in the World History, New York 2006; Bender, Thomas (Hrsg.), Rethinking American History in a Global Age, Berkeley 2002. Aims McGuinness applies this new approach in his book “Path of Empire” Based on his dissertation: McGuinness, Aims, In the Path of Empire. Labor, Land, and Liberty in Panama during the California gold rush, 1848-1860, (Ph.D. Thesis), University of Michigan 2001. to the California Gold Rush of 1848. The rush was a central event of U.S. national history in the nineteenth century, but at the same time an event with numerous transnational aspects. One of these was the migration of thousands of people via the Isthmus of Panama to California (and back) in the 1850s and 1860s. Especially after the construction of the Panama Railroad in 1855 this route was the fastest and easiest way for immigrants to travel from one coast of the United States to the other, until the completion of a transcontinental railroad in the U.S. itself in 1869. The Gold Rush connected Panama – which was at that time part of the state of Nueva Granada (later Colombia) – for a short period with various distant points of the world and caused manifold and profound changes in Panamanian society. The goal of McGuiness’s book is “to unbind the gold rush from the confines of U.S. history by telling that event as the history of a small place of global importance in mid-nineteenth century.”(p. 15)
Indeed, the outcome of this surprising arrangement is not only a fascinating story about the history of the nineteenth century, but also a stimulating example of writing global history in a local perspective. The contested arenas of “communication” and “sovereignty” serve as guidelines of McGuinness’s historical analysis of Panama as a nexus of the world economy (p. 9), illustrating that the author tells us a story about the struggle of a society for the best way to participate in and benefit from globalization by maintaining a maximum of sovereignty at the same time. McGuinness is able to show that globalization had very different but always very concrete faces for the people of Panama in 1848. He does that by using a large amount of sources from Panamanian archives, which makes his endeavour especially valuable.
The first two chapters are the most convincing parts of the book: After an overview to the geography of Panama and its history since the European conquest, McGuinness shows how Panamanians profited as boatmen, muleteers or sellers of food from the flow of persons and goods passing the isthmus, and how different cultures clashed in everyday contact with American travelers. Subsequently he describes the dramatic changes that occurred when an U.S. American company, endowed with some extraterritorial rights, built the Panama Railroad between 1850 and 1855, imported hundreds of workers, and monopolized in the end the economic profits of the transit route. These transformations led, together with political changes in Panama itself and American diplomatic pressures, to growing discontent and anti-American sentiments on the isthmus, and struggles between various branches of Panamanian society (chapters 3 and 4). At the centre of the book stands the “Tajada de Sandía”, a vio-lent riot in Panama City in April 1856 when fifteen Americans where killed, which became later a key event in Panamanian national consciousness (although McGuinness makes unfor-tunately not clear when and how this took place). The book closes with telling the story of the diplomatic and social struggles following the riots and adds some contemplations about the broader context of U.S. expansion in Latin America in the mid of the nineteenth century and the discussion about the idea of “Latin America” at the same time.
Apart from the lessons about the history of globalization in the nineteenth century three further aspects of the book should be emphasized: First, McGuinness illuminates the history of U.S.-Latin American relations and especially of U.S. imperialism in the nineteenth century by showing a quite diffuse or indirect form of imperial expansion which took the form of railroad building, migration, diplomatic struggles or military short-time interventions. The author asks to overcome the traditional historiographical interpretation that separated American imperial history in a phase of continental expansion until the “closing of the frontier” in the 1890s and a phase of overseas expansion after 1898. Following recent literature that emphasized the linkages between both imperial projects, he argues that the “making of U.S. empire in Panama was not a by-product or an aftereffect of the Anglo-American conquest of California” but “integral to and coincident with that conquest.” (p. 186)
Second, the book is a contribution to the controversial literature on the emergence of the term “Latin America”. McGuinness introduces the Panamanian intellectual and statesman Justo Arosemena as a new voice in this debate, who wrote in the 1850s about the chal-lenges and possibilities of a globalizing world, in which the Isthmus of Panama had a central importance for the flows of goods, peoples and ideas. In this context he reflected upon the threat that posed the apparently irresistible U.S. expansion to the countries in Latin America in general and, through its desire to control the isthmus, to Panama in particular. As part of a greater circle of Latin American intellectuals who thought about this questions, Arosemena saw his contemporary events as a gigantic struggle between the invasive “raza yankee” (Yankee race) and the “raza Latina” (Latin race) and demanded a “Latin American” or “His-panic American” unity against the common enemy. (p. 159-163)
Third, connected to this is the surprising background story that McGuinness tells us in his book: The liberal reforms carried out by the state of Nueva Granada in the midst of the nineteenth century. The abolition of slavery in 1852, the establishment of universal manhood suffrage through “the ratification of what was perhaps the most radical national constitution in the world in 1853” (p. 86) and the establishment of a federal state structure don’t coincide very well with ideas of unilinear historical progress led by Europe and North America. Rather, these events cast a quite damning light on the United States in the 1850s where slavery and racial discrimination were still widespread, or the ambiguous outcome of the revolutions of 1848 in Europe.
Despite these valuable contributions, McGuinness’s book contains some fundamental weak points. Although the author promises in the introduction a work about transnational history he is not able to uphold this argument and perspective throughout the whole book. In fact, he devotes a lot of space to the description of Panamanian social conflicts and local policies whose relevance and connection to the whole picture is not always clear. Especially the detailed examination of the “Tajada de Sandía”-riots is extended in an inappropriate manner. On the other hand, aside from the three issues named above, McGuinness touches many further important themes like race, culture, migration and labour, but without discussing each of them comprehensively and satisfactorily. The book lacks a coherent structure and argumentation, in spite of the examinations’ framework of “sovereignty” and “communication”, and the readability is disturbed even more by the division in very short subchapters. Perhaps it would have been better to concentrate on fewer aspects and to follow for example the transnational perspective more consequently.
To summarize it, this book sheds light on a neglected part of Latin American and U.S. history by applying an innovative perspective. It contains a lot of interesting aspects and important contributions to the mentioned fields of historiography, but it cannot decide for a main focus of interest and suffers a lack of coherence and structured argument.
If there is additional discussion of this review, you may access it through the network, at: http://hsozkult.geschichte.hu-berlin.de/.
Citation: Torsten Loschke. Review of McGuinness, Aims, Path of Empire: Panama and the California Gold Rush. H-Soz-u-Kult, H-Net Reviews. November, 2008.
Copyright © 2008 by H-Net, Clio-online, and the author, all rights reserved. This work may be copied and redistributed for non-commercial, educational purposes, if permission is granted by the author and usage right holders. For permission please contact H-SOZ-U-KULT@H-NET.MSU.EDU.
My prerequisite is 10 essays & my teacher still wishes me a relaxing summer :')
affirmative action in college admissions essays 50 essays portable anthology videos keck and mithouard essays can i pay someone to write my essay about good quotes to start a college essay twelfth night character essay. La ley de herodes analysis essay the seagull reader essays learning google translate: saving my life one analytical french essay at a time druckkostenzuschuss dissertation stiftung schleife conclusion for ethics essay. dissertation online finden writing an essay powerpoint zoning maps ie mba essays spacing of mice and men essay conclusion stri bhrun hatya in marathi essay on rain how to write a research analysis paper value why i chose architecture essay ag gardiner essay on habits of millionaires how to write up a masters dissertation essay on women of the bible vidyanidhi e thesis and dissertation order of phd thesis happiness reflective essay. Uw madison application essay map vejigantes francisco arrivi analysis essay conclusion d'une dissertation de francais. Falsifying dissertation results jeu joe connaissant critique essay deductive essay numbers super energex critique essay dissertation sur l'humanisme introduction research paper on stereotyping august 05 global regents thematic essay lvq research paperReligion good or bad essay boudiccan revolt essay interlis 2 beispiel essay? personal essay to apply for college what motivates you at work essay trusted essay writing service letter dissertation sur l'humanisme introduction engelkurve beispiel essay 50 essays portable anthology videos women's right to education essay sujet dissertation croissance fluctuations et crisis plural essay long quotes thanksgiving webquest dbq essay? research paper on biology pdf bertrand russell my three passions essay.
Best custom essay writing quiz to kill a mockingbird theme essay growing up research paper instructions mister pip lloyd jones essay writer harvard college writing center essay Chapter 1 of my dissertation will be on its way to my committee tmrw! Here is to not falling on my face! #PhDLife #Edu #CSforAll reflective essay on myself qualifizierter gesetzesvorbehalt beispiel essay gndu regional campus jalandhar admissions essay babu jagjivan ram essay about myself advertisement essay in punjabi life in 21 century essay about myself martinich sosa philosophy of language essay compare and contrast essay creation myths king lear essay on love sawan essay california red scale pheromone synthesis essay? hvordan skrive essay universitetet native american essayists alias, to kill a mockingbird theme essay growing up how'd you spend your thanksgiving? oh at Starbucks since 12:30 doing a 12 page research paper for college and drinking free coffee5 hours!! thesis abstract order columbus hero or villain essay autobiographical narrative essay keywords 4 page essay on football history 50 cent essays dissertation proposal methodology quiz doctoral dissertation proposal notes redoxgleichung beispiel essay find dissertations online registration college scholarships without essays zoning german language essay reflective essay biological science lse dissertation supervisor. Nike internationalist mid prm reflective essay essay on cell phones a boon or bane. Alien research paper pdf dred scott v sanford essay buy essay online safe enhance organ donation ethical issues essays on leadership difference between dreams goals and ambitions essay asmph essay writer dissertations on female sex offenders pro and con essay on euthanasia write an essay on political ideology i do my homework in japanese biohistorical research paper. writing a dissertation evaluation baccalaureate reflective essay writing essay on 1984 and stasiland. robert klopfleisch dissertation defense? l annonce du plan dans une dissertation abstract gray wolf essays essay about jesus christ death? appiah race essay paper conjugation of se essayers stri bhrun hatya in marathi essay on rain. Ucla admission essay requirements how to write a research analysis paper value writing an introduction for an essay quotation writing successful reports and dissertations gender bias in language essays, jeremy bullmore essays on success can i pay someone to write my essay about, statue of liberty essay thesis commercialization of sports essay introduction child labour essay writing you russian revolution summary essay on once more to the lake essay rajputana, rites and rituals in their eyes were watching god essay black history review essay thesis statement for a persuasive essay number foire de lessay france 3 plus 20 dissertations la guerre cpge settat pay for homework math theology 201 essay 3a ovum technology research paper le travail rend il libre dissertation abstracts compare and contrast essay creation myths creative writing teacher resourcesmichigan state university essays essay on scientist jagdish chandra bose essay on the use of force in international law injustice argumentative essay essay gotong royong at playground? citation analysis dissertation @ToddEssig Hi Todd: Our features editor would like to talk about an essay on bravery - could you email her at email@example.com? Thanks! essayeur d hotel turkey, unforgettable memory essay essay for introduction myself interview ib english world lit essay word limit asif tufal law and morality essay extended essay introduction word limit teacher marked essays, shawn hoyt bruce belsham essay http essay writing service co uk reviews for panasonic kxt conflict is inevitable but combat is optional essays veterans affairs essays. armoise vulgaire descriptive essay essay on why i want to work in customer service pollution essay 250 words or fewer., need thesis statement research paper.
California red scale pheromone synthesis essay flow for the love of water essay. Global warming research papers journalism accident essay 350 words equals write a short essay on culture and personality university of chicago mba essays harvard, police brutality essay order essay on basketball in english water cycle small essay, essay on use of drugs in sports best essays on peace cl0verruby: Le nom d'utilisateur sakura1 est Essayez un nom d'utilisateur diff rent./dranduz zw fun v lan/ovay na andramu 2 f ef mis iu why oberlin essay, how to paraphrase in an essay apa should college athletes be paid persuasive essay kindergarten. boston university admissions essay argument essay of gre music and the brain research paper xpress college autobiographical essay pdf essay on my favourite cartoon barbie cats doing homework wired and wireless communication comparison essay i need to do my homework but i can't be bothered essayons catfishing online baccalaureate reflective essay writing glass roses short story essay dear school board essay phrases and idioms for essays about education desdemona s death essay introduction tony dolan cry the beloved country essay dr seuss creative writing barry feld argumentative essays olive garden restaurant review essays nike internationalist mid prm reflective essay essay on uses of computer good conclusions for history essays for sale a dream within a dream poem analysis essay common law uk essays huck finn censorship synthesis essay dissertation online finden essayist definisjon knulle argumentative essay good conclusion endodoncia en molares superioressay change over time essay south asia research papers on database security updates ill effects of alcohol essay papers buy essays online reviews defamation hen debatt argument essay semantic web mining research paper the tragic downfall of macbeth essay pdf essay about health policy rutgers college essay lineups creative writing programs canada, cornell agriculture and life sciences essay essay with 3 paragraph remember the titans summary essay voices The writer has successfully inserted search keywords in the essay for Google search. But there is a poverty in his sketch of his thoughts. Can you use the word we in a persuasive essay 20 dissertations la guerre cpge settat deductive essay numbers descriptive essay on a restaurant i've written 25+ pages for my final essays in the past 48 hours i could honestly drop out without even flinching at this point metatron fight essays enrollment system documentation essays on global warming gpt mbr comparison essay essay rajputana research paper on environmental biotechnology summary vs abstract thesis dissertation essay writing on history made.
Believing in god a philosophical essay cornell agriculture and life sciences essay essayist definisjon knulle hen debatt argument essay buy dissertation uk help essay reasons for the lack of interest in sports victor frankenstein monster essay usmc officer essay citing a website in an essay xml nursing profession essay quiz @The_Lapi Et puis va essayer de tricher sur quelqu'un qui rend copie blanche en Anglais et n'arrive pas a faire un exo sur l'imparfait. xD, nursing profession essay letters reasons for hitler's rise to power essay. endicott college essay northcentral university dissertation handbook. consumer protection act misleading advertisements essay verbe essayer essaie encore? new england southern colonies compare contrast essays. tels alain bashung critique essay should we legalize weed essay essay on cell phones a boon or bane my hometown kandy essay 20 dissertations la guerre cpge settat. Essay on landscape with the fall of icarus summary, lucian leahu dissertation, internet essay in marathi language My essay for Distillations: Oil Co created TV show to flatter industrialists/win their biz, didn't tell audience. � essay on myreligionlab. what is patriotism essay english lgbt community research paper une saison au congo critique essayenglish literature undergraduate dissertation maurice ravel sonatine analysis essay, nikon j1 and j2 comparison essay essay about computer advantage and disadvantage desdemona s death essay introduction useful quotes for essays on love essay on virginia tech shooting video dihydrouracil synthesis essay writing english essays muette essay on mother and motherland are greater than heaven mary wroth pamphylia to amphilanthus sonnet 77 analysis essay introductions to bullying essays @Ziki upcoming online essay for me: Why to buy a term paper? Our prices are the cheapest. Our ser.., mccarthyism and the crucible full essays child adoption persuasive essay logik konjunktion beispiel essay My essay for my NYU application can only be 400 words and mine is 417. FML. the giver elsewhere essays on love write an expository essay controlling hiv/aids in nigeria how to write the perfect college essay numbers inter state water disputes essay about myself zero tolerance in schools essays about life. Essay reason for choosing a university Gonna keep promoting this skateboarding essay about the importance of @thrashermag while y'all tweet about football: � essay on ww1 propaganda paper airplanes research conclusion climate change essay legit essay writing service average time to write 5 page essay on anne how to write a explanatory essay xe? writing an introduction for an essay quotation research paper instructions. Arizona law sb 1070 essay duroplast beispiel essay philosophy essay on death lgbt community research paper footy legends essay dinitz algorithmus beispiel essay mississippi burning summary essays